Concise, clear rules, which are all completely reasonable and should be followed and used as rules for more communities. I don't like haters either and believe they should have consequences. Helpful criticism is much better. Thanks to everyone here who contributes anything for all of us to use. What a great community!
I believe that the rule regarding images needing to be included with a resource is a bit silly in my opinion. I think that it should be removed/edited so that instead of having your resource taken down, a message should be sent to the 'uploader' explaining what they need to fix. I think all rule breakers without malicious intent should be notified of what they did wrong. (Crib related broken rules)
There are a few things on the secret project I'd like to comment on that may improve it in the future;
I feel like the main page can be easily spammed with resources from the same person all at once which kind of overwhelms and 1-2 resource users how many have some good stuff but it won't bee seen. maybe limit how many can be posted in a given time (like once every 15-30 mins) which can be done in xenforo permission (I know as I run a xenforo forum myself with this addon).
There is also a lack of categories
maybe spreading out the GFX to have logos, banner ,thumbnails, intro, outros along with one for renders(for people who make HD background images) as separate categories, this will make it easier for people to find what they are looking for.
There are a few things I would add to this either as rule or as an option(or both) when upload your template and that is:
An option that would be if its for personal use only(something like this : you have permission to use this on your channel or any you manage however you may not re sell or re package this in any way to profit off of the sale or transfer of it or claim it as your own work) or free (meaning it doesn't matter if you have ads and you make money while using it ofc aslong as you don't claim it as your own work) I think adding what I said would really help ^-^~ Either than that great rules :P